Zoning Board rejects CTC variance application
Pago Pago, AMERICAN SAMOA — For the second time in just over a year, local construction company Continental Transport Corporation (CTC) has been denied permission by the American Samoa Zoning Board to establish its retail and production operations at a new location.
The latest rejection came after the board voted to deny CTC's zoning variance application for a site in Tula, where the company had proposed relocating its operations after failing to secure approval for an earlier proposal in Leone.
CTC's planned operation included the retail sale, hauling, and storage of cinders, sand, rock aggregates, and other construction materials. The company also sought approval for laboratory testing of construction materials, rental of heavy equipment, truck and heavy machinery maintenance and repair services, and the manufacture of concrete and construction products.
With its administrative offices located in Pava'ia'i, CTC operated for more than a decade from its former production and retail headquarters in Fogagogo near Maliu Mai Beach Resort.
However, that chapter came to an end in 2025 when the company's lease expired and was not renewed.
After losing its Fogagogo location, CTC sought alternative sites from which to continue its operations. Company officials reportedly applied for space at the government-owned Daniel K. Inouye Industrial Park in Tafuna but were informed that no suitable lots were available.
The only government-owned property available at the time was a tract of land in Vailoa, Leone, commonly known as the "Airstrip."
CTC subsequently sought zoning approval to operate from the Airstrip property, but the proposal generated widespread opposition from nearby residents.
The site is surrounded by residential neighborhoods and is located near Leone High School, Leone Midkiff Elementary School, the Western District Health Center, the Leone Police Substation, and numerous family homes.
Residents packed public hearings before the Zoning Board, voicing concerns about dust, noise, heavy truck traffic, environmental impacts, and potential health risks. Written objections were also submitted to board members.
The strong community opposition ultimately played a significant role in the Zoning Board's decision to deny the Leone application in August of last year.
Undeterred by that setback, CTC returned to the Zoning Board last month seeking approval for a new site in Tula.
The proposed location sits on communal land belonging to the extended family of company owner Tony Togia'i.
Appearing on behalf of her husband, who was off-island at the time, Mrs. Togia'i told board members that the family had granted permission and fully supported the company's plans to establish a brick-manufacturing operation on the property.
She said CTC had gone to considerable lengths to gain community support before submitting its application.
According to Mrs. Togia'i, the company met with families living near the proposed site and received their approval. She submitted a petition bearing the signatures of those who supported the project.
She also informed the board that CTC had already invested substantial sums in specialized equipment, including a brick-manufacturing machine, and had constructed a purpose-built building designed to contain noise produced by the operation.
Mrs. Togia'i emphasized that brick production would only occur during designated daytime hours to minimize disturbance to neighboring residents.
Toward the end of last month, Zoning Board members Jim McGuire and Fofoga Sagato conducted a site inspection of the proposed Tula facility.
During their visit, they observed that there appeared to be no residences immediately adjacent to the operation.
Company owner Tony Togia'i accompanied the board members and explained the scope of the project. He also indicated that only one neighboring resident remained opposed to the operation.
The following day, McGuire visited that resident, Falaula Silivelio Vaoesea Aofia, to hear firsthand the concerns that had prompted his objection.
In an interview witnessed by Samoa News, Aofia described a very different picture of life next to the proposed CTC operation.
The retired U.S. Army veteran said construction activities on the site began approximately two years ago and involved extensive excavation work, heavy machinery activity, and large-scale earthmoving operations.
According to Aofia, the work has significantly affected the quality of life for his family.
"The breeze that comes from the ocean side of the village blows directly toward our home," Aofia explained. "When they operate the heavy machinery, the cement mixers, and the brick-making equipment, the noise is loud and the wind carries large amounts of dust toward our house."
He said the situation has become particularly difficult because of existing health conditions affecting both him and his wife.
"The air we breathe has become unsafe," he said. "It aggravates respiratory problems and prevents us from opening our windows or spending time outside."
Aofia noted that his wife is wheelchair-bound and suffers from respiratory ailments that could be worsened by dust generated by the operation.
He added that he also faces numerous health challenges and receives full medical benefits through the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs.
Aofia stated that he suffers from Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) resulting from his military service and said the constant noise from heavy equipment can trigger anxiety and stress.
The retired veteran also expressed frustration about how information regarding the project was communicated to residents.
Aofia said he believed he should have been informed much earlier about the proposal before it reached the Zoning Board.
He specifically questioned why the village pulenu'u had not made greater efforts to notify residents about a project that could directly affect their lives.
His frustration intensified when he reviewed the petition submitted by CTC in support of the application.
According to Aofia, he recognized many of the names on the document, including the signature of the village pulenu'u, who is also his first cousin.
Another signature that drew his attention belonged to a neighbor employed by the Department of Health.
Aofia said he had previously asked the individual to report what he viewed as health concerns associated with the operation to appropriate authorities.
Visibly upset, Aofia questioned how so many people who were familiar with his family's concerns had nevertheless signed the petition supporting the project.
Last Friday, as the Zoning Board met in executive session to make final decisions on pending variance applications, Aofia made an unexpected appearance.
To the surprise of several board members, he personally delivered a formal written complaint detailing his objections to the CTC operation.
Aofia explained that he had learned of the meeting through board members who had visited the site and felt compelled to ensure that his concerns were placed on the record before a final decision was made.
After considering the matter, board members voted to deny CTC's zoning variance application.
The decision marks the second unsuccessful attempt by the company to secure a new location for its operations following the loss of its longtime Fogagogo site, leaving the future location of one of the Territory's largest construction-material suppliers uncertain.

![Falaula Silivelio Aofia (right) stands outside his Tula residence with his wife, who is wheelchair-bound, and their granddaughter during a visit by Zoning Board member Jim McGuire (left) to discuss Aofia's concerns about the proposed CTC operation located near his family home. [photo: Asi A. Fa'asau] zoning board visit](https://samoanews.com/sites/default/files/styles/slideshow/public/field/image/img_7446.jpg?itok=VaNH98Vi)