Butler to appear before Senate GOIC today
Pago Pago, AMERICAN SAMOA — The Senate Government Operations Investigative Committee (GOIC) is scheduled to hear testimony this morning from Governor Pulaali'i Nikolao Pula's Executive Advisor on Finance, Brett Butler, as lawmakers continue their investigation into the controversial $10.1 million investment of American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) interest earnings.
Committee members are seeking answers regarding insurance coverage that administration officials have repeatedly stated was obtained to protect the investment. Specifically, senators want details concerning the amount allegedly paid for the insurance, the date the payment was made, and any documentation supporting the transaction.
According to the committee's request, Butler is expected to provide records and clarify the circumstances surrounding the insurance arrangement, which has become a central issue in the Senate's ongoing inquiry into the investment.
Lawmakers are also seeking clarification of comments made recently by Governor Pulaali'i during a press conference, where he suggested that senators may have been questioning the wrong parties regarding the insurance coverage.
The Governor's remarks came after representatives of Trade and Merchant Trade Services and Southern Pacific Insurance Company appeared before the committee and denied having any direct contractual relationship with the American Samoa Government concerning the investment.
During that hearing, company representatives testified that they had not directly dealt with ASG and had not issued an insurance policy guaranteeing the return of the Territory's $10.1 million investment.
Those statements appeared to conflict with earlier testimony from administration officials who told lawmakers that the investment had been insured.
Asked about the discrepancy during his press conference, Governor Pulaali'i responded that "the Fono had talked to the wrong people."
Butler subsequently attempted to explain the arrangement, stating that the insurance protection was not purchased directly by ASG from Southern Pacific Insurance or Trade and Merchant Trade Services.
Instead, according to Butler, the insurance was part of a broader structure involving McKinley Beech Tree (MBT), the entity connected to the investment transaction.
He explained that ASG's funds were not to be released until there was an insurance mechanism in place to protect the investment.
According to Butler, MBT retained the services of an insurance broker known as First Gate, which in turn worked with Trade and Merchant Trade Services.
Trade and Merchant then allegedly arranged for Southern Pacific Insurance Company to act as an insurer or guarantor associated with the transaction.
Under that explanation, MBT worked through its broker to coordinate the coverage, while Trade and Merchant and Southern Pacific Insurance provided the financial backing for the arrangement.
However, the exact nature of the relationship among those entities, and what protection was actually provided, remains unclear and is expected to be a major focus of Wednesday's hearing.
In addition to seeking proof of any insurance payments, senators want Butler to explain the specific roles played by each of the companies mentioned throughout the investigation, including MBT, First Gate, Trade and Merchant Trade Services, and Southern Pacific Insurance Company.
Committee members have indicated that they are attempting to establish a clear chain of responsibility and determine whether the insurance arrangement described by administration officials is the same arrangement discussed by representatives of the off-island companies.
The hearing is expected to be closely watched because it follows testimony by company officials that has raised new questions about the existence, scope, and beneficiaries of any insurance coverage associated with the $10.1 million investment.
Senators have stated that obtaining a definitive explanation of the insurance arrangement is critical to determining whether adequate safeguards were in place to protect public funds before the investment was made.

